Hoof wall resection and update on Blackie the laminitis case.

     This is Blackie a previously posted laminitis case.  Click here to see previous radiographs and venograms. He is showing response with added sole depth and comfort. A hoof wall resection was required and I thought it would be a good representation as to what to expect from a hoof wall resection.

Below are radiographs from immediately post deep flexor tenotomy and 60 days post tenotomy.  Noteworthy change on both are additional sole depth under tip of coffin bone.  However continued remodelling of the tip of the coffin bone and a slight increase in palmar angle on the left hoof are suggestive that the dorsal portion still fails to grow at a rate similar to the palmar portion.  This hoof suffered more damage as it was the "club".  Deep flexor tenotomy was not performed at the recommended time.  Significant pathology was identified within 5 days of onset of acute laminitis but owner refused tenotomy at that time.

   
   
     A resection is required in laminitis cases that have coronary band swelling that is prolapsing over the hoof wall.  The hoof will act as a tourniquet as the inner laminae experience swelling.  The lack of expansion of the hoof creates massive vascular compression and starves the laminae and coffin bone of needed nutrient flow.  Often times this is all secondary to inflammation arising from compromised soft tissue and bone along the toe and medial quarter as this area tends to receive the most significant load induced vascular compromise when laminae fail to suspend the coffin bone.

     I like to use a cast cutter or multi-purpose oscillating saw to cut through the hoof.  Usually an 1 1/2 in below the hairline is a minimum and often times I find myself removing more at a later date.  The width of resection will depend on amount of coronary band involved and should extend at least  1/2 in wider than the affected coronary band.

   

Next I use a sharp hook on the end of hoof knife to round and smooth the proximal (upper) edge of the  intact hoof wall.  It is important to perform this prior to removing hoof wall because it will get somewhat bloody after removal and occlude good visualisation. 

Next the hoof wall can easily be removed by grasping one end with half rounds or regular nippers.  Ease of removal is directly related timing of resection.  Resections based on early evidence from venograms are usually more attached  versus the case that has already separated and has drainage.  

One removed, a gentle massage of the coronary papillae and lamina to encourage hemorrhage and lay the papillae in a more normal position pointing downward. Note the lack of hemorrhage in the most compromised region.  

Next 1/2 inch felt heavily coated in silvadene cream is cut to fit the void left behind.  This is tightly wrapped with elastikon as adequate pressure is important to prevent excessive swelling and granulation.  Many times with cases that are far away and I am uncomfortable with the owners ability to maintain a bandage, I will place a cast over the elastikon up to the fetlock to maintain adequate compression.  Preferably, daily changing for the first three days to ensure adequate hoof wall has been removed is recommended.  After that a cast can be applied and changed every 7-10 days or bandage changes every 3-4 days.  Each time a new piece of felt is applied with a fresh layer of silvadene.  I will also use dmso gel applied to the coronary band to aid with inflammation.  

  

Images below are representative of what the hoof will look like at bandage or cast changes.  This will depend greatly on the amount damage or compromise present.  This case has significant damage with a lot of granulation already present.  Ideally a resection should have been performed much earlier to prevent this level of damage to the coronary papillae.  The first thing you will see is secretion of the secondary matrix horn which signifies the cornification process.  Once this has covered the entire resection site, compression bandaging can be stopped and patient can go without any bandage at all.  I like to see the cornification at the level of the previous hoof wall prior to stoppage of bandaging or casting.  

    Below are images of 5 days post resection.  Notice the medial (inside) and lateral (outside) portions have already began to fill in with secondary matrix horn.  The central portion suffered so much damage that the lamina are dead and unable to secrete matrix.  This will fill and contract very similar to a wound anywhere else on the body via epithelialisation.  A moist environment maintained with bandaging and/or cast will expedite the process.

Below are images from approximately 15 days later.  A cast was placed over felt pad and elastikon for this period.  Note the matrix is at the level of the hoof wall at the medial and lateral aspects and the granulation is reduced to 1/3.  

These images are approximately 30 days post resection.  Continued epithelialisation and secondary horn formation aka cornification.  

Images below are about 6 weeks post resection and complete epithelialisation and cornification has occurred.  At this point it is no longer necessary to apply cast or compressive bandages unless coronary band begins to get inflamed again.  

Acute laminitis case showing the value of the venogram

This is an acute laminitis case that was initially painful and exhibiting the typical founder stance on December 16 2012.  No known cause but a mild colic episode had occurred 3 days prior.  I was able to perform venograms on what I would consider Day one of laminitis.  These plain film radiographs and venograms create a baseline in which to compare follow up venograms.  This allows assesment of the mechanical therapy applied and severity of compromise in the days to follow.  Venograms 5 days later show moderate compromise already.  Consider the amount of compromise present while treated with mechanics. Unloading the Deep flexor tendon, its forces applied to the dorsal lamellar zone and sole directly below tip of coffin bone via raising the palmar angle.

There is no measurable displacement of the bone but significant change has occured within the vascular network as early as five days.  Some financial constraints existed and it was decided to wait 30 days and repeat venograms to evaluate if the mechanics applied would be enough.  I warned the client at this point that a deep flexor tenotomy may need to be performed as this rapid progression is very concerning.  Ideally a repeat venogram in another 4-7 days would have been best but finances limited to a 30 day check.  Knowing what I know now about this case I would have cut tendons on day five and never looked back.  Below is the Day one venogram on the left compared to the Day five Venograms on the right side.  Focus your eyes on the circuflex artery, terminal papillae and the vasculature directly below the tip of coffin bone.  Moderate compression and diplacement of these vessels five days into the syndrome.  Remember that no measurable rotation, increase in h/l zones, loss of sole depth has occured.

After applying the modified ultimates on day one the horse began to make a clinical improvement noted by moving around in stall better and better appetite.  He no longer rocked back to make turns.  This is important to consider as clinical signs alone are not good indicators of how the case is going.  The horse will lie to you when comes to laminitis.  

Right Front venogram comparson Day one to Day five

Left Front Venogram comparsion Day one to Day five.

Day 5

Day five

 

Below are venograms that are 30 days post laminitis of the left front.  Note the circumflex is several milimeters above the tip of the coffin bone and no papillae are present.  I again recommended deep flexor tenotomy as the modified ultimates are not providing enough mechanical relief, through unloading the force of the deep flexor.  The tenotomy abolishes all forces applied to the bone to hoof attachments and solar corium directly below tip of coffin bone.  Finances prohibited the Owner from going the surgical route and horse was actually improving with regard to pain and we decided to wait another thirty days.  

30 Days Post.  The Circumflex artery is displaced several mm above the tip of the coffin bone and the solar vasculature is tightly compressed below the tip of the coffin bone.

Below are 60 day post radiographs.  Note the increased C/E distance, diverging H/L zones (rotation),and loss of sole depth, especially on the Left.  No growth is noted on examination of the dorsal hoof wall and about 1/4 in at the heels is noted. Just to recap, we have no measurable displacement of the bone until 60 days into the syndrome but significant vascular changes on day five that continues to fail despite mechanical therapy.  If you are waiting to diagnose laminitis based on rotation you are 60 days late in this case.  

60 day post insult radiograph.  Note changes in ce, hl zones and sole depth.

60 Days post initial insult.  Note diverging hl zones (some may call rotation) increased in ce and comparable decrease in  sole depth.

Below are comparative venograms of the left front.  On the left is day one and on the right is 90 days after intial insult.  Note the greatly altered circumflex architecture and the tip of the coffin bone is visualized below the solar vessels.  Moderate thickening of the dorsal sublamellar zone and significant accumalation of contrast  as the dorsal coronary band that is likely secondary to a septic process that is brewing.  Horse still has not grown any sole or dorsal hoof wall in 90 days.  Note the scallop like loss of bone that occurs just above the tip caused by displacement of the terminal papillae and circumflex artery.  I can only assume the combination of local hydraulic pressure and possibly the redirected papillae in this area are to blame for this unique change in the shape.  At this stage in the game many irreversible changes have occurred that will likely prevent this horse from returning to a previous level of competition.  

90 days post comparison

90 days post comparison .  The right foot has suffered less but prominent and significant change/damage has occurred in the area of the circumflex artery and terminal papillae.

Left front Post tenotomy and derotation.  

Right Front post tenotomy and derotation.

At the 90 day examination I advised the client that surgery was the only option for treatment and this late in the game I could only offer a guarded prognosis for any return to previous level of performance.  The owner opted to donate the horse for a learning seminar.  On March 22, 2012 a little over 90 days post initial insult a eager bunch of vet students and farriers performed venograms, applied derotation shoes and performed deep flexor tenotomies.  In the days following the horse is moving much better.  I will post followup radiographs in 30 days to evaluate the progress.  I do feel recovery is still very likely.  Ideally performing the tenotomy prior to irreversible damage and bone change would result in a better outcome.

In conclusion I would like to re iterate the important points:

1)  In hindsight a deep flexor tenotomy should have been performed on day five or very shortly after.

2)  Improvement with regards to pain and movement are not good indicators of success in laminitis.

3)  Radiographic measurements alone, early in the syndrome, may change very little if any and a venogram may be the only information alluding to the nature of the insult.

4)  Aggressive early mechanical therapy did relieve a lot of pain but did not provide enough unloading of the Deep digital flexor to aid in unloading of the vascular supply and further unloading via deep flexor tenotomy would have likely given a better outcome if performed earlier.

Stay tuned!

Images from the October clinic with Dr. Ric Redden.

Hello,  I wanted to thank all the attendees to the in depth equine podiatry lecture and demo with Dr. Ric Redden of International Equine Podiatry Center.  We had some very good cases in which to apply a sound and methodical radiographic and external evaluation.  Using this evaluation a therapeutic shoe was apply to aid in rehabilitation of each case.  

We are planning a follow up clinic November 17th to recheck and reset each case.  This will be a great opportunity to see the response radiographically.  

This first case is a grade 2+ club cases used as western and english pleasure as well as some roping.  

This is a case with navicular bone changes that had responded to increase in palmar angle and reduction in digital breakover but was not consistently going sound.  Dr. Redden applied an aluminum rocker rail.  Look at the TSA and the distance the navicular is from the proximal p2 between the pre and post shoe radiographs.

This patient has had some undiagnosed recurring lameness.  Today no in depth workup was performed but a shoe to enhance foot mass recovery and increase sole depth was applied.

This is a many year chronic laminitis.  Goal with the rockered aluminum rail is to decrease DDFT tension unloading the apex of the coffin bone and the tension forces at the horn/lamellar zone.  This places breakover in the center of articulation.  This will improved compromised circulation in the dorsal region of hoof and a more even hoof growth from toe to heel is expected as well as improved sole depth.

This case had an acute bout of laminitis about 6 months ago.  Venograms show that circumflex is above the apex of  coffin bone and compressed tightly to tip of coffin bone as well.  Dorsal lamellar zone on the right front is broken and a void of contrast is present at coronary plexus.  No solar papillae are evident even at an increased to 20 degree palmar angle which should unload DDFT by 60 percent.  Treatment included derotational shoeing followed by a deep digital flexor tenotomy.